Taming Toddler Bedtime Battles: How to Handle Stalling, Get Your Evenings Back, and Help Your Toddler Sleep
Lacy Hess • April 27, 2025
Simple Solutions for Toddler Bedtime Battles: Tips for a Smoother, Stress-Free Night
If your toddler seems to have mastered the art of bedtime stalling—needing just one more hug, a fourth trip to the potty, or yet another book—you are not alone.
Many parents find themselves dreading the nightly routine that was once sweet and predictable. But take heart—these stalling tactics are common, and with the right strategies, you can bring calm and consistency back to bedtime.
How Much Sleep Do Toddlers Really Need?
Before diving into behavior, let’s talk about sleep totals. Toddlers generally need between 10 to 12.5 hours of sleep in a 24-hour period, which includes overnight sleep and a daytime nap. The exact amount can vary based on age:
• 1–2-year-olds
typically need around 12–12.5 hours
• 3–4-year-olds
usually need about 11–12 hours
• 5–6-year-olds
tend to need closer to 10–11 hours
So, for example, if your 3-year-old
is going to bed at 7:30 PM, waking at 6:30 AM, and still napping 1.5 hours
during the day, they're getting 12.5 hours of sleep scheduled into their day—which is great!
But if bedtime has become a struggle, one possibility is that your toddler may not need quite that much sleep anymore. A slight adjustment to bedtime or nap duration might help restore a smoother nighttime routine.
What to Do if Bedtime Is Becoming a Battle
If your toddler is getting more sleep than their body actually needs, it can sometimes lead to bedtime resistance—think stalling, protests, or full-on meltdowns. When a child isn’t tired enough at bedtime, falling asleep can feel like a chore rather than a natural transition.
If this sounds familiar, consider trying one of these simple adjustments:
• Push bedtime back by 30 minutes.
• Shorten the nap, if possible. (This one can be tricky if your child is in daycare.)
Even small changes to your toddler’s sleep schedule can make a big difference in how easily they settle at night. The goal is to find the right balance of total sleep that leaves them well-rested but still ready for bed when the time comes.
Consistency Is Key: Set Limits and Stick to Them
Toddlers thrive on routine—but they’ll also test limits at every chance they get. Here are some specific examples of how to manage common bedtime stall tactics by setting clear expectations and following through every single time:
• Potty Trips:
“Okay, you can go potty one more time, but this is the last time. No more potty trips after this.”
And stick to it.
• Extra Hugs:
“You can give two more hugs, then it’s bedtime.”
Give the hugs right then, and gently remind them of the boundary if they try to delay later.
• More Books:
“You can pick two books for tonight. Which ones will it be?”
When the extra books come out, let them know those can be for tomorrow.
• Interrupting Story Time:
“If you don’t sit and listen, I’ll have to stop reading.”
Follow through, and let them try again tomorrow if necessary.
• Getting Out of Bed:
Calmly and firmly walk them back. “It’s bedtime. You can sing to yourself or talk to your stuffed animals, but you need to stay in bed.”
If they keep getting up, say: “You can walk back or I’ll help you back.”
Then do it. Every time.
Use a Bedtime Pass System for Extra Motivation
A great tool for toddlers who love pushing boundaries is a bedtime pass system. Here’s how it works:
• Decorate a few index cards together as “bedtime passes.”
• Explain that they can use the passes to come out of their room (for a hug, water, etc.).
• Once the passes are used up, there are no more extra visits.
• If they don’t use their passes, they can trade them in the next morning for a small reward like:
- Picking breakfast
- Choosing a game for game night
- Earning 1:1 time with mom or dad
Start with 2 or 3 passes and adjust based on how many times your child tends to come out of their room.
Be Firm, Calm, and Consistent
Staying calm while your toddler pushes boundaries is tough—especially at the end of a long day. But yelling or getting upset only fuels the fire.
Take turns with your partner if needed, and remind yourself: consistency now leads to smoother bedtimes later.
When you calmly hold the line, your toddler learns what to expect. After a few nights of consistent responses, bedtime resistance usually fades.
Offer Choices to Foster Cooperation
Toddlers love feeling in control. Giving them simple, controlled choices helps reduce power struggles. For example:
• Let them check off a bedtime checklist.
• Offer a choice between two pairs of pajamas.
• Ask: “Do you want to brush teeth by yourself, or do you want me to help you?”
If they refuse to choose, follow up with: “You have 5 seconds to choose, then I’ll help you. 5…4…3…”
If you step in to help, keep it gentle and encouraging. For example:
• Put your hand over theirs to help with brushing.
• Walk with them to the bookshelf to clean up.
• Hold their hand to guide them back to bed.
Any cooperation—even with help—deserves praise.
Positive reinforcement will go a long way.
Make Bedtime a Time of Connection
Remember: toddlers resist bedtime in part because they don’t want the connection with you to end.
So lean into it! Make the routine fun and special:
• Read books in silly voices.
• Add a short, made-up story with your toddler as the main character.
• Keep screens and distractions away.
Your full attention is often the most powerful motivator of all.
You’ve Got This!
Bedtime doesn’t have to be a nightly battle. With structure, calm consistency, and a little creativity, you can help your toddler wind down and look forward to bedtime again.
If you’re looking for personalized strategies that work for your unique child, I can help!
Book a free 30-minute consultation
and let’s talk about how to bring sleep back to your home.
Oh! And don't forget to sign up for my free newsletter to get weekly sleep tips straight to your inbox!
Lacy's Lullabies - Pediatric Sleep Consultant
Wondering if screen time is affecting your child’s sleep? Learn how screens can disrupt melatonin production, trigger bedtime battles, and what simple changes can help your child fall asleep easier and stay asleep longer.
Is your 12-18 month old suddenly fighting sleep? Learn the common causes of the 12-18 month sleep regression and simple strategies to help your toddler sleep better — and bring peace back to bedtime.
